first_img In a logical world, the EU would never risk the fallout of Britain crashing out with no deal at all Tags: Brexit People Theresa May At a dinner the other week, a friend of mine wondered whether Theresa May would have been treated with quite so much patience, forbearance and courtesy by her EU colleagues had she not been a woman. It’s a fair question.Her reportedly dismal performance at the EU summit on 21 March must have been enough to make everyone present tear their hair out. With no plan put forward in the event that her deal is once again voted down in parliament (which seems likely now she has made enemies of almost all MPs), the European Council was forced to take matters into its own hands. Read more: A Norway Plus compromise is the worst of both Brexit worldsThe approach offered is an elegant one. If the deal is approved, an extension until May allows the necessary legislation to be passed. If the deal is voted down, the UK will have two weeks to decide what to propose next. The new Brexit date in those circumstances is set at 12 April.Or is it? Can the EU really contemplate a no-deal exit? I would argue that it is difficult, if not impossible, for the EU to do so.The deal is stuck in the UK parliament for one reason and one reason only: the Irish backstop arrangements. These are deemed essential by the EU, whose leaders will not countenance a hard border in Ireland. They have stood steadfastly by the Irish government in their implacable resistance to removing the backstop or making it unambiguously time-limited.If it were not for the backstop, it is highly likely that the withdrawal agreement could have sailed through parliament. Share whatsapp Or would it prefer a no-deal exit which ensures that the very thing that has destroyed the possibility of a deal – the Irish border question – actually comes to pass immediately?It is not clear to me how and why the EU could possibly prefer the latter option. It would be a clear case of cutting off your nose to spite your face.Read more: Brexit live: Rees-Mogg throws support behind May’s dealAnd which option would the Irish government prefer? Would it really hold out for an unmodifiable backstop if the alternative were a hard border today and having to carry the political fallout? Such stubbornness does not make logical sense.But then again, much of what has happened around the Brexit debate is entirely illogical. And so it will continue while May remains Prime Minister. All the runes suggest that may not be for long. City A.M.’s opinion pages are a place for thought-provoking views and debate. These views are not necessarily shared by City A.M. But it is obvious (though nobody seems to have said it loud and clear) that a no-deal Brexit would require a hard border in Ireland.The UK has already stated that it would not enact such a border. It would therefore be left to the Irish to do so, and to carry the political fallout from such border infrastructure.Whether such a unilateral arrangement can last is debatable. But it does not have to last long for it to have a significant short-term political effect.If the UK continues to reject the withdrawal agreement because of the backstop, the EU will have a choice: stick by the position that the agreed text is sacrosanct and opt for a no-deal Brexit; or modify the backstop. Both these choices involve throwing Ireland to the wolves – something that the EU has, so far, refused to contemplate.In those circumstances, would the EU prefer a deal that, by making the backstop clearly time-limited, minimises the economic cost of Brexit for all parties and avoids a hard Irish border in the short term at least, while creating a strong incentive for both parties to reach a workable future relationship?center_img Tuesday 26 March 2019 11:26 am Opinion whatsapp by Taboolaby TaboolaSponsored LinksSponsored LinksPromoted LinksPromoted LinksYou May Likebonvoyaged.comThese Celebs Are Complete Jerks In Real Life.bonvoyaged.comBleacherBreaker4 Sisters Take The Same Picture For 40 Years. Don’t Cry When You See The Last One!BleacherBreakerDefinitionMost Embarrassing Mistakes Ever Made In HistoryDefinitionFilm OracleThey Drained Niagara Falls – Their Gruesome Find Will Keep You Up All NightFilm OraclePost FunA Coast Guard Spotted Movement On A Remote Island, Then Looked CloserPost FunZen HeraldEllen Got A Little Too Personal With Blake Shelton, So He Said ThisZen HeraldMisterStoryWoman files for divorce after seeing this photoMisterStoryNoteableyJulia Robert’s Daughter Turns 16 And Looks Just Like Her MomNoteableyHealthyGem20 Hair Shapes That Make A Man Over 60 Look 40HealthyGem More From Our Partners Police Capture Elusive Tiger Poacher After 20 Years of Pursuing the Huntergoodnewsnetwork.org980-foot skyscraper sways in China, prompting panic and evacuationsnypost.comNative American Tribe Gets Back Sacred Island Taken 160 Years Agogoodnewsnetwork.orgFlorida woman allegedly crashes children’s birthday party, rapes teennypost.comAstounding Fossil Discovery in California After Man Looks Closelygoodnewsnetwork.orgRussell Wilson, AOC among many voicing support for Naomi Osakacbsnews.comBrave 7-Year-old Boy Swims an Hour to Rescue His Dad and Little Sistergoodnewsnetwork.orgMatt Gaetz swindled by ‘malicious actors’ in $155K boat sale boondogglenypost.comA ProPublica investigation has caused outrage in the U.S. this weekvaluewalk.comBiden received funds from top Russia lobbyist before Nord Stream 2 giveawaynypost.comKamala Harris keeps list of reporters who don’t ‘understand’ her: reportnypost.comConnecticut man dies after crashing Harley into live bearnypost.comKiller drone ‘hunted down a human target’ without being told tonypost.comUK teen died on school trip after teachers allegedly refused her pleasnypost.comMark Eaton, former NBA All-Star, dead at 64nypost.com‘Neighbor from hell’ faces new charges after scaring off home buyersnypost.comInside Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis’ not-so-average farmhouse estatenypost.comWhy people are finding dryer sheets in their mailboxesnypost.com Joe Zammit-LuciaDr Joe Zammit-Lucia is a co-founder and trustee of Radix, the think tank for the radical centre last_img

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *